Benny’s Pizza Palace and Social Club Menu (2025 Update)
Welcome to Benny’s Pizza Palace and Social Club, a culinary gem located at 1601 Monterey St, San Luis Obispo, CA. This lively eatery specializes in deep-dish pizzas that are decadent, cheesy, and served with a unique flair. Each slice bursts with flavor, as the signature red sauce is delicately layered on top to keep the crust crispy and fresh.
The menu doesn't stop at pizza—guests rave about their mouth-watering meatballs, savory lasagna, and crispy buffalo wings, making it clear why locals consider this spot a must-visit. Complimenting the food is an inviting selection of sides, including traditional ranch and zesty pesto, perfect for any palate.
The relaxed ambiance, coupled with attentive service and live music, ensures a delightful experience every time you visit. Benny’s isn’t just about food; it’s about community, vibrant vibes, and shared moments over extraordinary dishes.
BABY Pizza
BABY Ba-Kaww
Chicken, Garlic, sundried tomato, artichoke hearts, ricotta, pesto sauce
BABY Benny Pepps
Pepperoni, Mozzarella, Red Sauce
BABY Cheese
Extra Mozzarella, red sauce
BABY STIX
Mozz, spices
BABY Dad Bod
BBQ Sauce, Pork Belly, Mozarellan, onion, arugula
BABY G.D.B
Pepp, Saus, Ham, mush, bell, Mozz, onion, red
BABY Hot N Fun Guy
saus, mush, onion, mozz, red
BABY Itallian Stallion
Meatball, Salami, Onions, Pepperoncini, Mozzarella, Benny's famous red sauce
BABY Meat Kingdom
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, mozzarella, red sauce
BABY Veggie
Bell , onion, olive, mush, mozzarella, red sauce
BABY The Murphy
CLASSIC B.Y.O
Mozz, Red, Choice of toppings
CLASSIC Ba-Kaww
Chicken, Garlic, Sundried Tomato, Artichoke Hearts, Ricotta, Mozzarella, Pesto
CLASSIC Benny Pepps
Pepperoni, Mozzarella, Red Sauce
CLASSIC Cheese
Extra Mozzarella, red sauce
CLASSIC STIX
Mozz, spices
CLASSIC Dad Bod
BBQ Sauce, Pork Belly, Mozarella, onion, arugula
CLASSIC G.D.B
Pepp, Saus, Ham, mush, bell, Mozz, onion, red
CLASSIC HOT N FUNGUY
Sausage, Mushrooms, Onion
CLASSIC Itallian Stallion
Meatball, Salami, Onions, Pepperonicini, Mozzarella, Benny's Famous Red Sauce
CLASSIC Meat Kingdom
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, mozzarella, red sauce
CLASSIC Veggie
Bell , onion, olive, mush, mozzarella, red sauce
CLASSIC Murphy
CLASSIC
Dessert
Tiramisu
Cinnastix
1/2 BASKET
Chicken Nugs
Corn Dog Bites
Fries
Mojo Potatos
Mozzarella Sticks
ONION RINGS
Wings
The GD FAM
FROZEN TO GO
FROZEN Lasagna - MEAT
FROZEN CHEESE
FROZEN BABY CHEESE
FROZEN PEP
FROZEN BABY PEP
FROZEN BRIAN
FROZEN HAWAIIAN
FROZEN MISC
FROZEN MEAT BALLS 4
FROZEN MEAT BALLS 8
BABY Leftover
CLASSIC Leftover
MONTHLY SPECIALSPIZZA OF THE MONTH
Salad
Antipasta Salad
Pepp, Ham, salami, Ice, Romaine, carrot, mush, cabbage, olives, tom, croutons, mozz
Mixed Arugula
fresh arugula, onion, sun dried tomato, walnut, parmesan
Caesar Salad
Romaine, tomatos, croutons, parmesan, crouton
House Salad
ice, romaine, carrot, mush, cabbage, olive tom, croutons, mozz, pepperoncini
Pasta Salad
Bleu Cheese
Hot Honey
Marinara
Ranch
Korean
Buffalo
Creamy Buffalo
Pesto
Side Celery
Cheese Sauce
Italian
Sides
ITALY
Garlic Bread
Bowl O' Meatballs
Lasagna
SINGLE Meatball
Medium Chicken Spaghetti Pesto
Pesto, Chicken, garlic, Sun-dried Tomato, Parmesan
LARGE Chicken Spaghetti Pesto
Medium White Sauce Spaghetti
White Sauce, Parmesan
LARGE White Sauce Spaghetti
White Sauce, Parmesan
BYO SMALL Pasta
BYO LARGE Pasta
Small Chicken Spaghetti Pesto
Pesto, Chciken, Garlic, Parmesan
Small White Sauce Speghetti
Mac 'N' Cheese
Macaroni noodles and house made velveeta cheese sauce